The second death occurred on a Thursday, though Arthur would not learn of it until Friday morning. The intervening hours were a fog of pain and laudanum, the tincture Dr. Wren had prescribed when the sleeplessness became unbearable. Arthur hated the stuff. It left him cotton-mouthed and dull-witted, his thoughts moving through treacle. But it bought him oblivion, and oblivion was the only mercy he could afford.
He had spent the days following the tribunal in a state of suspended collapse. The routine of his life, once so rigidly maintained, had dissolved into a shapeless procession of hours. He woke when the pain woke him. He ate when hunger became more insistent than despair. He sat in his armchair, the newspaper spread across his lap, and read and reread the article about Herbert Finch until the words blurred into meaninglessness.
The scrapbook had migrated from the bottom drawer to the desk. He no longer pretended it was an accident, a forgotten hobby from some fevered episode. He added to it now with deliberate care, clipping articles from the newspapers he bought with his dwindling pennies, pasting them into the pages with the precision of a man who had spent his life arranging information. The Harrowgate murder was only the beginning. The Mercury, Mercia’s most sensational daily, had dedicated its front page to the Ragman’s return, and its competitors had followed suit. Every detail of the original killings was exhumed and reexamined. Every suspect who had been questioned and released was named again, their alibis scrutinized by journalists who had no stake in accuracy.
Arthur read them all. He learned that the Ragman’s first victim, in 1926, had been a woman named Florence Cavendish, a former factory worker who had claimed disability for a respiratory condition while running a laundry business from her kitchen. She had been found in her own washroom, bound with strips torn from a bedsheet, the word “DISALLOWED” pinned to her bodice. The second victim, a bricklayer named Thomas Murchison, had collected benefits for a crushed hand that had, according to anonymous informants, healed well enough to allow him to play the accordion in public houses on Saturday nights. The third had been a clerk, like Arthur, a man named Reginald Pettigrew who had falsified medical certificates with the help of a compliant physician. The fourth, the fifth, the sixth. By the time the killings stopped in the autumn of 1928, there had been nine victims in total, each one accused of defrauding the system that Arthur had once believed in, each one executed with the same ritual precision.
The police had been baffled. The Ragman left no fingerprints, no witnesses, no clues beyond the calling cards that were at once a signature and a taunt. The investigating officer, a Chief Inspector named Malachi Quince, had pursued the case with an obsession that bordered on madness, but the trail had gone cold in the winter of 1928, and Quince had retired two years later, a broken man who spent his final days muttering about the one that got away.
Arthur read these accounts with the absorption of a scholar studying a sacred text. He noted the patterns, the inconsistencies, the gaps in the narrative that the journalists filled with speculation. He observed that the Ragman had never killed anyone who had not first been accused, publicly or anonymously, of fraud. The accusations came first, like a whistle blown in the dark. Then the Ragman came, like an answer.
He did not ask himself why he was compiling this information. He did not examine the impulse that drove him to the newsstand each morning, that made his heart quicken when he saw the Mercury’s headline, that filled him with a savage satisfaction every time another fraudster was exposed. He simply did it, the way a river flows downhill, the way a wound bleeds.
Friday morning arrived grey and cold, the sky pressing down on the rooftops like a lid on a pot. Arthur dressed slowly, his back protesting every movement, and made his way down the stairs with the halting gait of a man twice his age. Mrs. Gudgeon was in the hallway, polishing the brass doorknob with a rag that had seen better days. She did not speak to him. She had not spoken to him since Tuesday, when he had failed to produce the rent money he had promised. Her silence was louder than any words could have been.
The newsstand on the corner was doing brisk business, a cluster of men in cloth caps and worn overcoats gathered around the vendor like moths around a flame. Arthur hung back, waiting for the crowd to thin, and when he finally reached the front, the vendor’s face was alight with the grim excitement of a man who has terrible news to impart.
“Another one,” the vendor said, slapping the folded paper into Arthur’s palm. “Found him in Wharfdale this time. Same handiwork. Same calling card. He’s back, alright. The Ragman’s back.”
Arthur paid his penny and retreated to a doorway, where he could unfold the paper without being jostled. The headline was even larger than before, a black banner that stretched across the entire front page: “RAGMAN’S SECOND VICTIM IN A FORTNIGHT: WHARFDALE WIDOW FOUND STRANGLED.” Below it, a photograph showed a narrow house on a terrace, its windows blank and staring, a constable standing guard at the door.
The victim was a woman named Edith Chalmers. She had been a widow for twelve years, collecting a survivor’s pension from the Mercia Social Insurance Board while supplementing her income with piecework as a seamstress. According to the article, an anonymous letter had been sent to the Board two months earlier, accusing Mrs. Chalmers of conducting an illicit business as a moneylender while claiming poverty for the purposes of her pension. The letter had been filed, investigated, and eventually dismissed for lack of evidence. But someone, it seemed, had not been satisfied with the Board’s conclusion.
Someone had entered Mrs. Chalmers’ house through the back door, which the police had found unlocked. Someone had bound her hands and feet with strips of cloth torn from her own sewing basket. Someone had pinned a scrap of paper to her apron, upon which was written, in the same irregular but deliberate hand, the word “DISALLOWED.”
Arthur read the article three times, his eyes moving over the words with the mechanical regularity of a typewriter carriage. When he finished, he folded the paper carefully, tucked it under his arm, and began the slow walk back to his lodgings. The rain had stopped, but the pavement was still wet, and his reflection skittered across the puddles like a ghost trying to escape its body.
Back in his room, he opened the scrapbook to a fresh page and began to work. He trimmed the article with a pair of sewing scissors he had borrowed from Mrs. Gudgeon’s kitchen months ago and never returned. He spread paste on the back with the careful evenness of a man who understands that disorder is the first step toward chaos. He positioned the clipping precisely, smoothing out the wrinkles with the flat of his hand.
When he was finished, he sat back and looked at his work. The page was full now, the two new murders joining the archive of the old. Florence Cavendish, Thomas Murchison, Reginald Pettigrew, the others whose names he had memorized. Herbert Finch, the fraudster of Harrowgate. And now Edith Chalmers, the widow of Wharfdale. Eleven lives, ended by a single hand, a hand that wrote “DISALLOWED” in letters that were irregular but deliberate.
He studied the word for a long moment. Then, without quite knowing why, he took up his pen and wrote it himself, practicing the letters in the margin of the scrapbook. The ink flowed from the nib with the smoothness of long habit, but the result was different from the newspaper’s description. His letters were too regular, too neat, the product of twenty-three years of clerical discipline. The Ragman’s letters, the article had said, were irregular. Imperfect. Human.
He tried again, deliberately roughening his strokes, allowing the pen to wobble and skip. The result was closer, but still not right. It looked like what it was: a tidy man’s imitation of messiness. The Ragman’s hand had been described as “irregular but deliberate.” A hand that was awkward without being careless, as if the writer were accustomed to precision but forced to operate under conditions that made precision impossible.
Arthur stared at his practice words until the ink dried and the light outside his window began to fail. He did not know what he was doing. He did not know why he was doing it. But somewhere in the depths of his mind, in the dark waters where thoughts moved without surfacing, a connection was being made. A bridge was being built between the man he had been and the man he was becoming.
That night, the pain was worse than usual. The dampness of the week had seeped into his bones, and his lower back screamed with every movement. He took a dose of laudanum larger than Dr. Wren had prescribed, hoping for the oblivion that had become his only respite. But the laudanum did not bring sleep. It brought dreams.
He dreamed he was walking through the streets of Mercia, but the city was different, older, its buildings twisted into shapes that defied geometry. He was not alone. A figure walked beside him, a shadow that moved in perfect synchronization with his own steps. The figure wore a long coat and a brimmed hat, and its hands were wrapped in strips of white cloth that fluttered in a wind Arthur could not feel.
“You know what must be done,” the figure said, and its voice was the rustle of paper and the scratching of a pen. “The system is broken. The tribunals are theater. Justice belongs to those who take it.”
Arthur tried to speak, but his voice was swallowed by the wind. The figure turned to face him, and for a moment Arthur saw what lay beneath the brim of the hat. It was not a face. It was a mirror, and in the mirror Arthur saw himself, but a version of himself that he did not recognize. This Arthur had eyes that burned with purpose. This Arthur held a pair of tailor’s shears in one hand and a scrap of paper in the other. This Arthur was smiling.
He woke with a gasp, his heart hammering against his ribs, his nightshirt soaked with sweat. The room was dark, the gas lamp having long since burned through its fuel. He fumbled for the matches on his bedside table, knocked them to the floor, and was plunged back into darkness before he could retrieve them.
He did not sleep again that night.
The following morning, he discovered the notes.
He had gone to his desk to retrieve the scrapbook, intending to add a new clipping about the police investigation into Mrs. Chalmers’ murder. But when he opened the drawer, he found something that stopped his breath. A sheet of paper, torn from the same cheap pad he used for his correspondence, lay on top of the scrapbook. On it, written in a hand that was not quite his own, were three sentences:
“Alfred Brimley, 14 Magpie Lane, Smethwick. Claims total disability for a back injury sustained at the foundry. Observed lifting a barrel of ale at the Red Lion public house on Saturday evening. Evidence sent to the Board, but no action taken.”
Arthur stared at the note for a long time. He did not remember writing it. He did not remember learning any of the information it contained. He had never heard of Alfred Brimley. He had never been to Smethwick. He had never visited the Red Lion public house.
And yet the note was in his handwriting. Not the neat, practiced hand of the clerk, but the rougher hand he had been practicing in the margins of the scrapbook. The irregular but deliberate hand. The Ragman’s hand.
His first instinct was to destroy the note. To tear it into fragments and scatter them into the grate, where no one would ever find them. His hand was already reaching for the paper when another instinct, colder and more calculating, stayed his movement. The note was evidence. If someone else had written it, if someone had entered his room while he slept and left it for him to find, then destroying it would be destroying a clue. But who would do such a thing? Who even knew about his scrapbook, his obsession, his secret practice with the pen?
No one. No one knew. He had told no one. He had seen no one. He had spent the past week in almost total isolation, leaving his room only to buy newspapers and the meager provisions his shrinking purse could afford. The only person who had any contact with him was Mrs. Gudgeon, and she was not the sort to play elaborate psychological games.
The alternative explanation was unthinkable. The alternative explanation was that he had written the note himself, in some fugue state brought on by laudanum and despair, and then forgotten the act entirely. That his hands, moving without the supervision of his conscious mind, had recorded information he did not possess. That somewhere, in the dark hours of the night, Arthur Cuthbert had become someone else.
He folded the note carefully and placed it back in the drawer, beneath the scrapbook. He would not destroy it. Not yet. First, he would verify. He would go to Smethwick. He would find 14 Magpie Lane. He would see Alfred Brimley with his own eyes, and he would determine whether the note was fact or fantasy, prophecy or madness.
The journey to Smethwick required two trams and a long walk through streets that grew progressively meaner with each step. The district was industrial, its air thick with the smoke of foundries and the clang of metal on metal. Children in ragged clothes played in the gutters, their faces pinched with a hunger that had nothing to do with food. Women in faded shawls watched from doorways, their eyes following Arthur with the suspicion reserved for strangers who did not belong.
Number 14 Magpie Lane was a narrow house in a terrace of identical narrow houses, their facades blackened by the soot of a thousand coal fires. The windows were curtained, the doorstep unswept, the general aspect one of neglect and decay. Arthur stood across the street, leaning on his cane, and watched.
For nearly an hour, nothing happened. Then the front door opened, and a man emerged. He was thickset, with shoulders that spoke of physical labor and a face that had been rearranged at least once by fists or accident. He moved with the confidence of a man in perfect health, his steps springy and unencumbered. He was carrying a set of bagpipes under one arm.
Arthur watched as Alfred Brimley walked to the end of the street and entered the Red Lion public house. Through the grimy window, he could see the man greeting friends, slapping backs, lifting a foaming pint to his lips with no sign of pain or limitation. He looked nothing like a man who claimed total disability. He looked nothing like Arthur Cuthbert.
The note was true.
Arthur stood on the corner of Magpie Lane until the light began to fade and the gas lamps flickered to life along the street. His mind was a whirlwind of confusion and terror and something else, something that felt disturbingly like vindication. He did not know how he had obtained the information about Alfred Brimley. He did not know why he had written it down in a hand that was not quite his own. But he knew, with a certainty that settled into his bones like cold water, that the note was only the beginning.
When he returned to his lodgings that night, he found a second note waiting for him. It was tucked beneath his pillow, a place he knew he had not looked that morning. The handwriting was the same irregular but deliberate hand. The message was shorter this time. Just two words.
“He knows.”
Arthur stood in the center of his room, the note trembling in his fingers, and for the first time in seventeen months, he forgot entirely about the pain in his back. Because someone had been in his room. Someone had left him a message. Someone was watching him, or guiding him, or setting a trap whose jaws he could not yet see.
He did not know whether the someone was a stranger, a phantom, or the reflection he had seen in the mirror of his dream. But as he looked at the two words written in the hand that was almost but not quite his own, he felt the boundary between those possibilities begin to dissolve.
The scrapbook sat open on his desk. The scissors lay beside it. And in the drawer, hidden beneath the clippings and the paste and the cheap paper of his correspondence, the first note waited like a seed that had already begun to sprout.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!