The prison library at Northern District Morgan County Correctional Facility was a converted storage room on the ground floor, its walls lined with metal shelves bowed under the weight of donated paperbacks and outdated legal reference books. The air smelled of mold and photocopier toner. The only window was a narrow slit near the ceiling that admitted a blade of gray light for approximately three hours each afternoon.
Vince Falco had been at NDMCCF for forty-seven days. He had learned the rhythms of the Special Housing Unit: the 6 a.m. head count, the 7 a.m. meal slot slid through the door, the 11 a.m. hour of recreation in a concrete yard the size of a basketball court, the 5 p.m. dinner, the 10 p.m. lights-out. The hours between were an ocean of silence that he had initially feared would drown him. Instead, he had learned to swim.
He spent every available hour in the library. The law librarian was an inmate named Clyde Decker, a former tax attorney serving seven years for embezzlement, who had turned his incarceration into an informal legal clinic for the prison's population. Decker was sixty-eight years old, with a stooped back and the delicate, precise fingers of a man who had spent a lifetime handling paper. He watched Vince with the skeptical patience of a teacher who had seen too many students lose interest when the material became difficult.
"You're back," Decker said on the forty-eighth morning, not looking up from the legal motion he was drafting on a manual typewriter. "Most high-profile defendants spend their time making phone calls to their lawyers, not reading civil procedure."
"My lawyer works for the people who put me here," Vince said. He had called Marcus Webb exactly twice. The first time, Marcus had assured him that the appeal was proceeding. The second time, three weeks later, Marcus had stopped returning his calls. Vince understood. The elders had given their instructions. The consigliere was no longer his consigliere.
"I need to understand how a federal civil rights complaint works," Vince said. "Specifically, Section 1983 claims against prison operators."
Decker finally looked up. Behind his wire-rimmed glasses, his eyes were sharp and assessing. "You want to sue the prison."
"I want to sue everyone."
Decker considered this for a moment, then pulled a heavy volume from the shelf behind him. It was the Prison Litigation Reform Act of 1995, its cover worn and its spine cracked. "Then you need to learn about exhaustion of administrative remedies. You can't just file a lawsuit. You have to file a grievance first, give the prison a chance to respond, appeal the denial, and only then can you knock on the federal court's door. The process takes months. Most inmates give up."
"I'm not most inmates," Vince said.
"No," Decker agreed, "you're not. I know who you are, Mr. Falco. Everyone in this facility knows who you are. The question is whether you know who you are anymore."
Vince took the book from Decker's hands. "I'm starting to find out."
The grievance that Vince filed on his fifty-second day of incarceration was handwritten on a standard prison form, its boxes filled in with careful block letters. He alleged that the conditions of his confinement violated the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment: inadequate medical care for a shoulder injury he had sustained during a fall in the shower, twenty-three-hour lockdown conditions that amounted to solitary confinement without due process, and systemic understaffing that created an unreasonable risk of serious harm. Each allegation was documented with dates, times, and the names of officers who had ignored his requests.
The grievance was denied six days later by the unit manager, a functionary named Griswold who wrote his rejection in red ink: "Inmate's claims are without merit. Medical care was provided. Conditions comply with facility policy."
Vince appealed. The appeal was denied by the warden's office. He appealed again, this time to the regional director of Cornerstone Corrections, the private corporation that operated the facility. The regional director's office sent back a form letter denying the appeal without comment. Vince filed the form letter in the expanding folder that Decker had given him, its tab labeled "EXHAUSTION," and began drafting the complaint.
He wrote in longhand on yellow legal pads that Decker procured for him at a markup of three commissary stamps per pad. He wrote during library hours, during recreation, during the long fluorescent afternoons when the other inmates on the tier watched television or played cards. He wrote with a focus that surprised him, the same focus he had once applied to real estate contracts and investor prospectuses, now channeled into the language of constitutional torts and equitable relief.
The complaint was titled "Lindsey v. Northern District Morgan County Correctional Facility et al." Decker had suggested the pseudonym. "Lindsey" was his mother's maiden name. It was common enough to be forgettable, obscure enough to avoid drawing attention from the prison administration until the complaint had been docketed. Vince signed the complaint as "John Lindsey, Inmate #48671," and on the seventy-third day of his incarceration, he placed it in the prison's legal mail system, where it would be forwarded to the United States District Court for the Eastern District without being opened or read by prison staff.
The complaint named seventeen defendants, including the warden, the unit manager, three corrections officers, and Cornerstone Corrections itself. It sought declaratory relief, injunctive relief, and compensatory damages of two million dollars. It alleged that the conditions at NDMCCF constituted a pattern and practice of constitutional violations that extended far beyond his individual case.
But the complaint was also something else, something that Vince had not discussed with Decker or anyone else. Hidden within its legal arguments, woven into the factual allegations like a thread in a tapestry, was a single paragraph that had nothing to do with prison conditions. It was a discovery request, carefully worded to fall within the scope of a civil rights action, that demanded the production of any and all documents related to the acquisition of the land on which NDMCCF was built. Vince had noticed something during his first week in the facility, something that had nagged at him like a splinter. The prison's main administration building had a cornerstone that read "1991," and the name on the cornerstone was not Cornerstone Corrections but "Falco Development Corporation."
His father had built the prison. Or rather, his father had built the building that later became the prison. Vince had been too young at the time to understand what his father was doing, but the pieces were beginning to form a picture. Giovanni Falco had constructed a facility in northern Morgan County in 1991, during the era when the federal government was aggressively expanding prison capacity. He had then sold or leased that facility to the entity that would eventually become Cornerstone Corrections. The terms of that transaction, and the ongoing relationship between the Falco family and the private prison operator, were buried somewhere in the corporate records that Vince's civil complaint now demanded.
On the eighty-ninth day of his incarceration, Vince received a response from the district court. It was not a ruling on the merits. It was a notice of case assignment. The case of Lindsey v. Northern District Morgan County Correctional Facility had been assigned to Magistrate Judge Daniel K. Brenner. Attached to the notice was a scheduling order that set a preliminary hearing for thirty days later, and a form for Vince to complete indicating whether he would require appointed counsel.
Decker read the notice over Vince's shoulder in the library. "Brenner," he said, a note of genuine surprise in his voice. "That's interesting."
"What do you know about him?"
"Not much. He was appointed three years ago. Former public defender. He's young for a magistrate, early forties maybe. He has a reputation for reading every page of every complaint, which most judges don't. He's also got a reputation for being unpredictable, which is either very good for you or very bad."
The preliminary hearing was held via video conference from a small room adjacent to the warden's office. Vince sat at a metal table, his hands uncuffed for the duration of the call, facing a monitor on which Judge Brenner's face appeared in slightly pixelated clarity. Brenner had a narrow face, dark hair receding at the temples, and the kind of tired, intelligent eyes that suggested he had seen too much of the world and had not yet decided whether to be cynical or hopeful about it.
"Mr. Lindsey," Brenner said, "or should I say Mr. Falco. I've read your complaint. It's unusually well-drafted for a pro se filing. I understand you had some assistance."
Vince glanced at the camera. "I've had time to learn, Your Honor."
"I'm sure you have. I'm going to allow the complaint to proceed past the initial screening stage, which is more than most prisoner petitions achieve. However, I want to be clear with you about what this case is and what it is not. This is a civil rights action alleging unconstitutional conditions of confinement. It is not a discovery vehicle for your pending criminal case, and it is not a forum for you to litigate your innocence or guilt in the Gallo matter. Do you understand?"
"Yes, Your Honor."
"Good. The defendants have filed a motion to dismiss. I'm going to deny that motion in part and grant it in part. The claims against the individual corrections officers in their official capacities are dismissed on sovereign immunity grounds. The claims against Cornerstone Corrections and the warden in his individual capacity will proceed. Discovery will be limited to the conditions-of-confinement allegations unless and until I rule otherwise."
He paused, and something shifted in his expression, a flicker of curiosity that he did not quite manage to suppress. "I will also note, Mr. Falco, that your complaint contains certain allegations regarding the ownership history of the facility. I'm not going to rule on the relevance of those allegations today, but I am going to allow limited discovery on that issue. If there is a connection between the conditions of your confinement and the entity that built this prison, that connection may be relevant to your Eighth Amendment claim. We'll see."
The screen went dark. Vince sat motionless for a long moment, the judge's final words echoing in his mind. The discovery door had been opened, if only a crack. And behind that door, he sensed, was something that Romeo Tassi and the elders did not want the world to see.
Three days later, Officer Harper appeared at Vince's cell door during the afternoon lock-in. Harper's face was unreadable, a professional mask that revealed nothing. "You have a visitor," he said. "Legal visit. The attorney's waiting in the conference room."
Vince had not requested an attorney visit. Marcus Webb was no longer returning his calls, and he had not yet been assigned appointed counsel for the civil case. He followed Harper down the corridor to the legal visitation room, a row of partitioned cubicles with Plexiglas dividers and telephones on both sides.
The woman waiting for him on the other side of the glass was not a lawyer. She was in her late forties, with short graying hair and a face that Vince recognized from photographs in his father's study. Her name was Margaret Chen, and she had been a junior prosecutor in the U.S. Attorney's Office in 1992.
She picked up the telephone on her side of the glass and gestured for him to do the same.
"Mr. Falco," she said. "You don't know me, but I knew your father. I worked on the organized crime task force from 1990 to 1996. I was one of the prosecutors who negotiated the non-prosecution agreement with Giovanni Falco in 1992."
Vince felt the air in the small cubicle grow heavy. "I don't know what you're talking about."
"Yes, you do. You've been asking questions in discovery about the 1991 land deal. That's what led me to you. I've been waiting twenty-eight years for someone to ask those questions." She leaned closer to the glass. "Your father made a deal, Mr. Falco. He agreed to provide information on rival families in exchange for immunity from prosecution. But that wasn't all he agreed to. He also agreed to build a facility that the government could use for high-security federal detainees. The Northern District Morgan County Correctional Facility was built with federal money funneled through a shell corporation. Your father was a contractor for the Department of Justice. The prison you're sitting in right now was your family's most valuable asset."
Vince said nothing. The pieces were shifting in his mind, forming a picture that was both horrifying and elegant in its symmetry.
"The day after your father signed that agreement," Margaret Chen continued, "he gave the government enough information to indict three rival families. Seventeen men went to prison. Your father walked free. And the prison he built became the place where some of those men served their sentences. I always wondered when the bill would come due."
She stood up, the telephone still pressed to her ear. "I'm not here to help you, Mr. Falco. I'm here because I've carried this secret for three decades, and I'm tired of it. The 1992 agreement is in the federal archives, sealed but not destroyed. If your civil case gets far enough into discovery, it will come out. When it does, your uncle Romeo will have to answer for what happened to Tony Gallo, because Gallo wasn't just a union president. He was the man who knew about the land deal. He was about to expose it when he died."
She hung up the telephone and walked out of the visitation room without looking back. Vince sat frozen behind the glass, the telephone still clutched in his hand, the dial tone buzzing in his ear like a warning.
Back in his cell that night, he lay on his bunk and stared at the ceiling, where a water stain had spread over the years into a shape that resembled a serpent eating its own tail. His father had built this prison. His father had made a deal with the government. His father had used the law as a weapon, and now the law had swallowed his son.
Somewhere in the administrative wing, Officer Harper was dialing a number he had dialed many times before. Somewhere in Portum, a phone was ringing in the private dining room of the Meridian, where Romeo Tassi was finishing his amaro and contemplating the next phase of a plan that had been set in motion long before Vincenzo Falco had ever dreamed of going legitimate.
The circle was closing. And at the center of the circle, alone in a green cell under fluorescent light, a man who had once imagined he could wash blood with water was beginning to understand that some stains were permanent, and some debts could only be paid by the next generation.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!