The August heat in Palmetto Parish pressed down like a wet wool blanket, heavy and suffocating, even at nine in the morning. The courthouse—a squat, yellow-brick building with a cracked portico and a clock that had stopped at 4:17 sometime during the Carter administration—groaned under the weight of its own decay. Inside, the air conditioner wheezed a thin, useless stream of coolness that barely reached the second-floor archives, where Ida Mae Thibodeaux sat on a rolling stool, her fingers stained with ink and dust.
She had been the secretary to District Attorney Horace Dufresne for nearly two years now, and she had learned to read the building like a patient. The floorboards told her when the sheriff was coming up the stairs (three creaks, a pause, two more). The radiator in the corner hissed at noon sharp, as if it, too, kept a lunch schedule. And the files—oh, the files—they had a language of their own. Some folders were fat with neglect, others thin with hasty closure. Ida Mae had developed a sixth sense for the ones that did not belong.
This morning, Dufresne had left for a fishing trip to Lake Pontchartrain, claiming he needed to "clear his head" before the governor's race heated up. He had left her a stack of old habeas corpus petitions from the early eighties, telling her to "sort the dead ones from the live ones." What he meant was: separate the inmates still breathing from those who had stopped troubling the system. She had done this before. It was clerical work, gruesome only in its banality.
She pulled the next box from the bottom shelf—a cardboard banker's box, water-stained and swollen, labeled "1979–1981, Misc. Writs." The tape had yellowed and cracked. She slit it open with her letter opener, a small brass thing her father had given her before he died of silicosis in the mills. Inside, the files were out of order, some pages stuck together with what looked like dried coffee, or worse.
The third folder in the box bore the name TATE, ELROY – DC# 44782. She pulled it out, curious because she remembered the name from a local news clipping her mother had kept—something about a man who had died in the parish jail awaiting trial for a barroom shooting. The folder was thin, almost empty. But tucked behind the standard intake form was a manila envelope, unsealed, the kind used for interoffice mail. It was a bright, almost garish yellow, which struck her as odd because the parish used only beige.
She opened it and found a single sheet of paper—a sworn affidavit, dated March 14, 1981, signed by Elroy Tate and witnessed by a notary she did not recognize. The affidavit was short, but every word landed like a stone in still water.
"I, Elroy Tate, being of sound mind and under no duress, do hereby state that on the night of October 22, 1975, I was paid the sum of five hundred dollars by Mr. Raymond 'Ray-Ray' Boudreaux, then campaign manager for State Senator Hollis Verret, to cause bodily harm to one Mr. Julian Cormier, a political opponent of Senator Verret in the parish council election. I did not intend to kill Mr. Cormier, but I struck him twice with a tire iron and left him by the levee. He died three days later. The coroner ruled it accidental drowning, but it was not. I was arrested for a different crime in 1979 and have been in custody since. I am writing this to clear my conscience. Senator Verret knows of this arrangement. I have sent him a copy of this statement."
Ida Mae's hand trembled. She set the paper down, then picked it up again, rereading the last line twice. Senator Verret—the same Hollis Verret who was now the front-runner for governor, whose face smiled from billboards along every highway from Baton Rouge to Shreveport. The same man who had shaken her hand at the parish fair last spring, telling her she had "fine, honest eyes." She had blushed.
She looked at the back of the affidavit. There was a handwritten note in blue ink, notarized as well, dated six weeks after the affidavit: "This statement is hereby retracted under duress from correctional officers. I was coerced by false promises of early release. Elroy Tate." And then, below that, in a different hand—perhaps a clerk's—a single line: "Tate died of myocardial infarction, June 12, 1981. Autopsy reclassified from 'pending' to 'natural causes.' Case closed."
Her throat tightened. The file was a graveyard. She flipped through the remaining pages—a medical report, a prison grievance form, a letter from Tate's sister asking for an investigation, all unanswered. The yellow envelope had been tucked so deep that no one had likely seen it in years. But why was it in a box marked "Misc. Writs" rather than destroyed or filed under evidence? And why was it here, in Dufresne's office, when the DA's jurisdiction had nothing to do with state senate affairs?
She heard footsteps in the hallway—two heavy, deliberate steps, then a pause. She slid the envelope and its contents into her lap, covering them with a stack of blank letterhead. The door opened, and Deputy Sheriff Lonnie Comeaux poked his head in. He was a lean man in his thirties with a sun-beaten face and a mustache that drooped at the corners. They had known each other since kindergarten, when he had pulled her pigtails and she had thrown a mudpie at his head.
"Ida Mae," he said, his voice low, almost a whisper. "You working on those old writs?"
"Just sorting," she said, forcing a calm she did not feel. "Dufresne wants them organized before the flood clean-up."
Lonnie stepped inside and closed the door behind him—an unusual gesture. He leaned against the filing cabinet, crossing his arms. "I came to warn you. There's talk around the sheriff's office that Verret's people are combing through old court records. They're looking for anything that might stick. And they're not shy about making things disappear."
Her heart beat faster. "What kind of things?"
"Witness statements. Autopsy reports. Anything that links certain deaths to certain campaign contributions." He looked at the box on her desk, then at her face. "You find something in there?"
She wanted to tell him. Lonnie was the only person in this parish she trusted with her life—and he had saved it once, pulling her out of a flooded creek when they were twelve. But something in his eyes, a flicker of fear she had never seen before, made her hesitate. She shook her head. "Just old burglary pleas and traffic citations. Boring stuff."
He held her gaze for a moment too long. "Be careful, Ida Mae. The governor's race is a blood sport down here. And the swamp doesn't care who it swallows." He tipped his hat and left, the door clicking shut behind him.
She sat frozen for a full minute, the yellow envelope burning a hole in her lap. Then she made a decision. She unfolded the affidavit again, reading it a third time, memorizing every detail: the dates, the names, the specific location on the levee. She took a pair of scissors from her desk drawer and carefully, surgically, cut out the signature block and the notary seal from the bottom of the page—not the whole document, just the part that could authenticate it later. She folded that small square of paper and slipped it into the inner pocket of her purse, the one with the broken zipper.
The rest of the affidavit she replaced in the yellow envelope, and then she stuffed the envelope back into the file, pressing it down so it looked undisturbed. She put the file on top of a pile of "closed" cases and carried the whole stack to the cart marked "DESTROY - FLOOD DAMAGE." Dufresne had already signed the disposal order. The parish maintenance crew would haul the cart to the incinerator by the end of the week.
She told herself she was protecting the evidence by removing it. But a smaller voice whispered that she was stealing—stealing a piece of a dead man's truth, stealing a choice that did not belong to her. She silenced the voice by focusing on the practical: her mother's medical bills, the bank's foreclosure notice taped to the refrigerator, the raise she would get if she kept her mouth shut and played along.
The afternoon crawled by. She typed letters, answered phones, filed a dozen mundane motions. At four o'clock, Dufresne called from the lake, his voice tinny and cheerful over the line. "Ida Mae, any messages?"
"Just the usual, Mr. Dufresne. A call from the sheriff's office about the budget. And someone from the state archives asking about old election records."
"Election records?" His tone sharpened. "Who?"
"Didn't leave a name. Said they'd call back."
"Don't let them near the 1975 files. Those are sealed by court order." He paused, and she heard the clinking of ice in a glass. "Actually, just tell them everything from 1975 was lost in the basement flood. That's the official line."
"Yes, sir," she said, her pen steady on the notepad. She wrote nothing down.
When she finally left the courthouse at six, the sun was a bruised orange smear above the cypress trees. The parking lot was empty except for her rusted Ford Pinto and a black sedan she did not recognize. The sedan had tinted windows and a license plate from Iberia Parish—three counties over. She walked to her car slowly, keys clutched between her fingers like a weapon. The sedan did not move. She got in, locked the doors, and pulled out onto Main Street, glancing in her rearview mirror. The sedan pulled out behind her, keeping a deliberate distance.
She took a series of turns—right on Magnolia, left on Bayou Road, a quick loop around the old cotton gin—and the sedan followed every move. Her palms were sweating. She considered driving to the sheriff's office, but Lonnie was off-duty by now, and the night shift deputy was a cousin of Verret's. Instead, she accelerated onto the gravel road that led to her mother's house, a shotgun shack on stilts at the edge of the marsh. The sedan stopped at the crossroads, its headlights blinking once, twice, then it turned around and disappeared.
She sat in her driveway for a long moment, her engine ticking as it cooled. The house was dark except for the kitchen light, where her mother, Lucille, would be boiling rice and okra. Ida Mae touched the pocket of her purse, feeling the small square of paper. She had not planned to become a keeper of secrets. But now she was one.
She walked inside, kissed her mother's cheek, and ate her dinner without tasting it. She helped her mother to the porch swing, where the old woman coughed into a handkerchief and spoke of the heat and the price of medicine. Ida Mae nodded, said yes and no in the right places, all the while replaying the affidavit in her mind: Senator Verret knows of this arrangement.
At nine o'clock, the telephone rang. It was a black rotary phone on the wall in the hallway, and its shrill bell cut through the stillness like a knife. Her mother was already dozing. Ida Mae picked up the receiver before the second ring.
"Hello?" she said.
A man's voice, low and smooth, with a Cajun drawl that curled around the vowels. "Miss Thibodeaux. You found a yellow envelope today. I'd like you to put it back where you found it—and forget you ever saw it. Do that, and you'll have a nice promotion by the end of the month. Don't, and I can't promise your mother's lungs will hold up through the winter."
The line went dead.
Ida Mae stood in the dark hallway, the receiver still pressed to her ear, the dial tone humming like a trapped bee. She looked out the screen door at the marsh, where the fireflies were beginning to blink, and she thought of Elroy Tate's cold heart, and Julian Cormier's drowning, and the levee that had swallowed every trace of a murder. Somewhere out there, a man with a smooth voice knew her name, her address, and her mother's illness.
She walked back to the porch and sat beside her sleeping mother, the humid night air wrapping around them both. She did not sleep that night. She stayed awake, counting the minutes until dawn, her hand resting on the purse that held her only piece of truth—and her only rope to hang herself with.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!